Everybody’s superstitious

I’ve been banging on about unhealthy religion, with the premise that it’s we that are more or less healthy, rather than religion per se.

Incidentally, it doesn’t really matter to my argument whether religion is an evolutionary by-product or the genuine reflection of reality I believe it to be. In fact, there’s no inherent dichotomy between the two – they’re not mutually exclusive positions. What I strongly reject is the idea that religion is merely man-made; it would I think be more reasonable to argue that humans are religion-made. Whether God or evolution (or both) hardwired us this way, we are inherently religious beings (see ‘Born to believe?’).


One of the less healthy forms our basic religious instinct takes is superstition. To this extent I agree with the New Atheists – where I disagree is that they view all religion as groundless superstition (and that they claim to be entirely free from religion themselves). Indeed, it was the ability of Christianity to liberate me from the superstition which had dogged me for most of my life (including many years of nominal churchgoing) that in part persuaded me that here at last I’d found the genuine article.

Having said that though, there can be a lot of superstition in our approach to and practice of the Christian faith – again, the problem is with us, not with Christianity itself.

What is superstition? I’d say that it’s characterised by fearfulness and magical (as opposed to rational) thinking, coupled with a belief in good and bad luck (or benevolent and baleful influences). So on the one hand there’s often a fear of particular objects, words, numbers, events or actions that are thought to bring bad luck; and on the other there’s a reliance on talismans, charms, mantras or ritual actions to attract good luck and ward off evil.

Bad luck is often associated with ‘the evil eye’, a malevolent spiritual force which is always on the lookout to cause mischief and harm; or else with demons, spirits, gods or ancestors who have to be appeased. Good luck may be associated with benevolent spiritual forces such as angels. But almost always the fear seems to be stronger; the bad luck trumps the good.

We’re all superstitious

I believe that a superstitious element is part of the psychological make-up of all humans, stemming partly from our childhood experiences and perhaps also partly from the primal and pre-scientific part of our evolutionary heritage – the childhood of our species if you like.

When we were young children, most of us were irrationally afraid of the dark, or avoided walking on the cracks in the pavement, or had particular ‘lucky’ or ‘unlucky’ numbers or objects, or little rituals and phrases to keep us safe. For children, with limited understanding of the world and depending almost entirely on adult protection, the world can sometimes seem fearful and unpredictable, full of unknown perils which become the monsters of nightmares and superstitious terrors. For some (like me), these superstitious fears and protective rituals can develop into a form of OCD, which in many ways is a psychological self-defence strategy to provide rudimentary (though ineffectual) boundaries and protective barriers though the use of anxiety-relieving rituals and repetitive litanies.

Of course, many otherwise rational and even atheist adults retain elements of superstition and ritual, for example touching wood, crossing fingers, asking to be ‘wished luck’, having a lucky number or item of jewellery, not walking under ladders, etc.

A recent trip to Lyme Regis was enough to remind me that superstition is alive and well under the New Age guise. In one of the town’s rock and fossil shops, every basket of stones and crystals was labelled with a legend like ‘thought to attract positive energy’ or ‘aids thought / helps with emotional issues / clears the bowels’ (I may be paraphrasing slightly). The scientist in me wanted to ask what tests they’d conducted to arrive at these conclusions. I’m pretty sure the majority of people who buy these stones don’t fully believe in their powers; for most there’s a kind of ‘well, it might work and it can’t hurt’ mentality – the more rational end of superstition if you like. I used to share an office with an agnostic ex-Catholic scientist who had a postcard of the Pope and a little statue of the Buddha on his desk, just to cover both bases (albeit largely in jest).

Superstition and religion

The more primitive and magical religions often seem to be merely a more spiritualised version of childhood superstition, though some are far more sinister. I recently read some BBC articles about Ugandan ‘juju’, and the kidnapping of children by ‘traditional healers’ (aka witch doctors) for blood rituals and even child sacrifices intended to bring good fortune and ward off evil. It’s horrifying stuff that seems to belong to another era, but it’s still very much active in the world.

It’s not just primitive or animist religions that are prone to superstition and magical thinking though; it’s a danger for all religions, even the most enlightened and sophisticated. Superstition and religion are both elements of the human psyche. They are not in fact the same, but they can all too easily get mixed up together, with inevitably unhappy results. (On the other side of the scale, reason and rationalism can become just as unhappily entangled.)

The tricky part is that almost any harmless element of life and of religion can become superstitious if it’s approached in a fearful or ritualistic way. Rituals, ceremonies and forms of words are a normal and often helpful part of community life; but there’s a key difference between ritual and ritualistic. The rituals and liturgies of most Christian denominations aren’t inherently superstitious, but at the same time any of them can become superstitious. For example:

  • Making the sign of the cross to ward off evil (as though the mere shape of the cross somehow has power in itself, or as though demons are so scared of it that they’ll flee at the sight)
  • Reciting the Lord’s prayer repetitively and without meaning or thought (or saying ten Hail Marys and fifteen Our Fathers)
  • Saying ‘in Jesus’ name’ at the end of every prayer; mindlessly repeating religious set phrases like ‘Hallelujah’ or ‘Praise God!’
  • Opening the Bible at random and seeing what verse comes up as though consulting an oracle or horoscope
  • Reading random everyday events as spiritual signs; interpreting every minor misfortune as God’s judgement or an attack of the devil
  • Regarding certain words or phrases as inherently powerful or dangerous, regardless of the speaker’s intent (e.g. I was once told not to say ‘blimey’ because it means ‘may God blind me’); fearing that words can invoke evil (‘speak of the devil and he pops up his horns’)
  • Treating certain objects, places or days with veneration, as though they had special power for good or ill
  • Being afraid of exposure to (say) Harry Potter or Halloween for fear of malign spiritual influences.

Of course, many of these things can be absolutely fine if done meaningfully and with good intent rather than in a superstitious way. There’s nothing wrong with people crossing themselves as a sign of devotion, or saying the Lord’s prayer, or using the phrase ‘in Jesus’ name’. It’s when they’re done mindlessly or fearfully – superstitiously – that there starts to be a problem.

Now I do actually believe that there are spiritual forces for good and evil abroad in the world; I’ve had some pretty terrifying encounters with the dark side of spirituality in the past, so I’m not wishing to downplay this reality. But when we think or act superstitiously we accredit these things with far more power and presence and influence than they really have. The world does contain many dangers, some spiritual, some material, many a mixture of both. But if we’re in Christ we don’t need to live in fear. (That’s part of what I was trying to get at in my recent piece on engaging with Halloween rather than running away.)

The mystery of the broken-down bus

As a postscript, it’s worth recording that just as I was typing “interpreting every minor misfortune as God’s judgement or an attack of the devil” above, my bus broke down; we all had to get off and get on another one, making me late home (and having to pay twice for the privilege). This was exactly the kind of minor misfortune which it would be very easy to attribute to spiritual causes, particularly given the coincidental timing.

So was it an attack of the devil, a divine practical joke, or just a meaningless coincidence? I’ve no idea, but either way it was a minor inconvenience and hardly worth getting superstitiously worked up about. Perhaps the devil does like to play annoying little tricks on us; I hope not, but either way superstitious fearfulness isn’t likely to help matters. Indeed, if the devil does exist and operate in this way, this kind of fearfulness surely plays into his hands and is exactly what he wants. Trusting in Christ, I want to choose to live free from fear even if the devil is real and active; what kind of a life is it otherwise?


About TheEvangelicalLiberal

Aka Harvey Edser. I'm a web editor, worship leader, wannabe writer, very amateur composer and highly unqualified armchair theologian. My heroes include C.S. Lewis and Homer Simpson.
This entry was posted in Controversies, Religion, Spirituality, Theology and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to Everybody’s superstitious

  1. Rosie Edser says:

    Another example of superstitous thinking – “things will go wrong today because I failed to have my Quiet Time this morning”


    • johnm55 says:

      Rosie, I think what sometimes happens with that type of superstitious thinking is that it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. You think that things will go wrong because you did or didn’t do ‘X’ therefore subconsciously you act to make things go wrong and thus prove yourself correct


    • Yes, sadly I have my own version of this – if I haven’t prayed for protection yet today, something bad might happen. I’m trying to be less superstitious about this but it’s a hard habit to break!


      • Oh, and another one – if you so much as glance at a horoscope you will be in deadly peril… or the old ‘if you go one mile an hour over the speed limit then your guardian angels will leave the car’. Mind you, given my recent speeding ticket I might have to reconsider that one… 😉


        • My daughter reminded me of an interesting superstition which many of us practice – how we try to cheat ‘Sod’s law’ (or Murphy’s) by, say, taking an umbrella out to make sure it doesn’t rain. Sod’s law is basically a de-spiritualised manifestation of the ancient bad-luck-rules principle for a more scientific age – ‘if something can go wrong, it will’.


  2. johnm55 says:

    What is superstition? I’d say that it’s characterised by fearfulness and magical (as opposed to rational) thinking, coupled with a belief in good and bad luck (or benevolent and baleful influences).

    I would argue that good and bad luck do exist. Some things in life are random or at least appear random to us. The arrival of of a 157 bus at the bus stop at the top of my road is a genuinely random event regardless of what the bus company may say. If one arrives ten seconds after I arrive at the bus stop I would consider that to be good luck, if one leaves the bus stop ten seconds after I arrive I would consider that to be bad luck. Where it tips over into superstition is if i start to think that the arrival or non arrival of the 157 is something that I can influence by wearing my lucky underpants.


    • Yes, I agree that luck exists in the sense of chance, and some chance (or apparently chance) events can have beneficial outcomes for us and others the opposite. Of course, longer-term it’s much harder to assess these kinds of impacts – good can often come out of apparent bad, and vice versa. But yes, there certainly seems to be an element of chance in life. What I’m querying is whether or not there are malevolent influences lurking out there waiting to pounce on us and bring about ‘bad luck’ if we say or do the wrong things, or if we don’t protect ourselves against them. I do believe in evil, but I don’t believe in bad luck in the superstitious sense… or rather, the rational part of me doesn’t, but the primitive/child part of me sometimes still wins out.

      I’m still not sure how much I really believe in ‘chance’ in a wider sense – whether or not God plays dice. My tentative view is that there’s a complex interplay between random chance, our choice and God’s action, and for any given event it’s almost impossible to be certain which influence was the greatest.


  3. Terry says:

    Harvey, didn’t the bus driver offer you a transfer ticket?

    Isaac had an accident on the 249 on Thursday and cut his head open. Of the six or so people on the bus, one was a teenager who had experience and qualifications in childcare, and she was able to help me clean and calm Isaac while we waited for the ambulance. She also accompanied me and Isaac to the PRUH in Farnborough. Coincidence? Good luck? God’s provision? I’m inclined to say the latter – but why?


    • Eric says:

      Were I a New Atheist, or of that mindset, I would say you shouldn’t credit God until you’ve ruled out the other possibilities. As is, I’d say you should thank your good Father for His provident ordering of the universe even if He didn’t “step in” with any special intervention in that case. Not that this is actually advice, but I think it’s a nice test case of the difference in the modes of thought behind each group.


    • Really sorry to hear about Isaac – hope he’s okay now?

      No transfer ticket sadly. Maybe I should have asked.

      These kinds of cases are almost impossible to interpret. From my own faith position, I’d certainly be inclined to put down the presence of the qualified teenager on your bus to God’s provision. It’s definitely also a coincidence, and even a piece of good luck in a sense, but neither of those rules out God being involved in it via secondary causes. (You’re the theological expert on God’s providence after all – maybe he’s showing you that it works in practice!)

      However, if there hadn’t been a qualified person present what would either of us have made of it? Perhaps God would have provided via another means, or perhaps there would have been another very different outcome.


  4. Ray Shoop says:

    Great article, I enjoyed it. I often professed not to be superstitious; in fact, I deliberately fought against it most of my life. I walked under ladders, chased down black cats, adopted the number 13 as my lucky number, and I realize this is in conflict. Most of my superstitions acquired at some point in life continue to exist simply because they evolved into habits I cannot shed, e.g., you will burn in hell for eternity if you use God’s name in vain. This was one of my greatest fears as a young child and I obeyed it. Until this day, I cannot do this, even though I am no longer a believer and I cuss like three sailors from hell. Habits can be a blessing or a curse, depending on which side of the fence you stand.


    • I lived at house number 13 for over 30 years, which was a little problematic for me when I went through a highly superstitious phase as a teenager! You’re right, it can be very hard to shake off these superstitious habits, even when you’re certain with all your rational mind that they have no basis in reality.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s